Concept design by Medeiros Web Design. Sunny Side is a fictional diner.
Baked at 4:30 AM
Pie, by the slice or whole.
Opal Harmon wrote these recipes on index cards in 1961. The cards are in a tin box over the oven, and we still bake from them every morning.
The five that are always here
$3.75 a slice, and $1.50 more with a scoop of vanilla. When a pie is gone, it is gone until tomorrow.
- Cherry
- Dutch apple
- Chocolate cream
- Coconut cream
- Pecan
- Cherry: tart cherries and a lattice top. Not too sweet.
- Dutch apple: a crumb top with oats and brown sugar.
- Chocolate cream: cooked pudding, never a mix, under real whipped cream.
- Coconut cream: toasted coconut on top. The first one gone most days.
- Pecan: Missouri pecans, and more of them than syrup.
One more, by the season
A sixth pie joins the case for a few weeks at a time, when the fruit is ready.
- March and AprilLemon meringue, piled four inches high
- May and JuneStrawberry rhubarb, and fresh strawberry with glaze
- JulyBlackberry, from a farm north of town
- AugustPeach, the two weeks the peaches are right
- September and OctoberPumpkin, and apple with a cheddar crust
- November and DecemberSweet potato, mincemeat on request, and peppermint cream
How they are made
- The crust is flour, lard, salt and ice water, rolled by hand. Opal's card says not to fuss with it.
- Fruit fillings are cooked on the stove first, so the bottom crust stays crisp.
- Cream fillings are stirred for twenty minutes and chilled for four hours.
- Twelve to sixteen pies a morning, and twice that on Saturday.
- One baker. Jean Lindsey has made every pie since 2004.
Whole pies
To take home
- Any of the five, 9 inch$18
- The seasonal pie$20
- Half and half, two kinds$20
- Deposit on the glass plate$3
Other baking
- Cinnamon rolls, a pan of six$16
- Biscuits, a dozen$9
- Fruit cobbler, feeds twelve$24
- Dinner rolls, a dozen$7
Order a day ahead by 2 PM. Sample prices for this concept site.
Holiday pies
- Thanksgiving: orders close the Sunday before. Pick up Wednesday from 6 AM to 2 PM. We are closed on the day.
- Christmas: orders close December 18. Pick up on the 23rd or the morning of the 24th.
- Easter: orders close the Wednesday before.
- The limit is 140 pies for Thanksgiving, since that is what one oven and one baker can do. Most years it fills.
- Paid when you order, and boxed with your name on it.
Keeping a pie
- Fruit pies
- Two days on the counter under a towel, then the refrigerator
- Cream pies
- In the refrigerator, and eaten within two days
- Pecan
- Four days on the counter. It freezes well for a month
- To warm a slice
- Ten minutes in a 300 degree oven, never the microwave
- To cut a cream pie
- A hot, wet knife, wiped between cuts
Ordering a whole pie
Asked about pie
Which pie should I try first?
Coconut cream, if there is any. If not, whatever Darla points at.
Do you make sugar-free pie?
A no-sugar-added apple, with a day's notice, whole pies only.
Can I buy the recipes?
No. Opal's daughter asked that they stay in the tin, and they have.
Can I get pie for breakfast?
It has fruit in it. Yes.
Want one for Sunday dinner?
Call by 2 on Saturday. It will be boxed and waiting at the register.