Concept design by Medeiros Web Design. Critical Hit Games is a fictional business.
Trade, sell and special orders.
Games you have finished with are worth something. Bring them in, and take home credit, cash or something you have not played yet.
What we take, and what we pay
| Item | In store credit | In cash | Condition |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trading card singles worth $5 or more | About 60% of our selling price | About 50% | Near mint. Played cards for less |
| Bulk cards | $4 a thousand | $3 a thousand | Any, sorted or not |
| Board games | 30 to 40% of what we will sell them for | 25 to 35% | Complete. We count the pieces |
| Role-playing books | 35 to 45% | 30 to 40% | No loose pages |
| Miniatures, unbuilt | 40 to 50% of new | 35 to 40% | On the frame |
| Miniatures, built or painted | By the piece | By the piece | Well painted armies sell for more |
| Dice, mats and accessories | A little | Not bought for cash | Clean |
How a trade-in works
1
Bring it to the counter
Any day before 8 PM. Big collections, call first so someone is free.
Photo ID needed
2
We look it over
Cards are checked against today's prices on a screen you can see. Games are opened and counted.
Ten minutes to an hour
3
You get one number
For credit, and one for cash. Take either, some of each, or take your things home.
No pressure
4
Paid on the spot
Credit goes on your account and never expires. Cash up to $200, a check above that.
Done
Card singles
- The bindersAbout 40,000 cards, sorted by game, set and color. Ask for a binder at the counter and take a seat.
- The caseAnything over $20 is behind glass, graded by condition and priced that morning.
- The dollar boxesThousands of commons and uncommons, four for a dollar. Where decks get finished.
- A want listLeave us the cards you are after. We text when one comes in, and hold it three days.
- Deck helpBring your list. Someone at the counter will find the cheap version of every expensive card.
The used shelf
By the front window. Every game has been opened, counted and sleeved up again.
A
Like new
Punched and played once or twice. Usually 25% under the new price.
B
Well loved
Worn box, everything inside. 40 to 50% under. The best value in the shop.
C
Missing a piece
Marked with what is gone, and priced to match. We often have the spare.
$5
The rescue bin
Odd lots, old editions and orphaned expansions. All $5.
Special orders and preorders
- Anything in printIf one of our four distributors has it, it is here in about a week.
- No deposit under $60Above that, a quarter down. We text the day it lands and hold it two weeks.
- PreordersNew releases at 10% off if you order before the release date. Pick up on the day.
- Out of printLeave a want. Things turn up in trade more often than you would think.
- Crowdfunded gamesWe back several a year as a shop. Ask what is coming, and reserve a copy.
At the counter, too
Missing pieces
A drawer of spare meeples, cubes, dice and card stands.
Free, if you bought the game here. A dollar if not.
Sleeving
We sleeve a deck or a whole game's cards while you play.
Two cents a card, and the sleeves.
Paint matching
Bring the figure. We find the color, or the two that mix to it.
Free, with advice thrown in.
Before you bring a collection
Questions about trading
How do you set card prices?
From the going market price that day, on a screen turned so you can read it. We pay a set share of that, and tell you the share.
Why is credit worth more than cash?
Since you will spend it here. It costs us less, so we pass the difference to you: 20% more.
I found my old cards in the attic. Are they worth anything?
Maybe. Bring them in. Looking is free, and we will tell you which few matter before you sell anything.
Can I trade a game straight for another?
Yes. Credit from the trade goes against anything in the shop that day, new or used.
Clear a shelf. Fill it again.
Trades are taken every day until 8 PM. For big collections, call ahead.