Concept design by Medeiros Web Design. Rainline Gutters is a fictional business.

Leaf guards.

Some houses need them and some are wasting money on them. Here is how to tell, what the kinds are and what each really keeps out.

Do you need guards at all?

Four kinds, honestly compared

Installed prices are for this concept site
KindKeeps outLets throughLastsInstalled
Stainless micro-mesh on an aluminum frameLeaves, needles, seeds and shingle gritAlmost nothing. Pollen film needs brushing off20 years and more$8 a foot
Perforated aluminum coverLeaves and twigsPine needles and maple seeds20 years$5 a foot
Reverse curve hoodLeavesSeeds, and water overshoots in heavy rain20 years$12 to $20 a foot, from others
Foam or brush insertsLeaves, for a year or twoSeeds sprout in them2 to 5 yearsWe do not fit them
Plastic snap-in screensBig leavesMost things, once they warp3 to 5 yearsWe do not fit them

We fit the first two. Micro-mesh is what goes on nine houses in ten.

What your trees drop, and when

  • Maples

    Seed helicopters in May, by the bucket. Then leaves in October.

  • Oaks

    Stringy catkins in April that mat like felt. Leaves late, into December, and acorns.

  • Pines

    Needles all year. They slide through any hole bigger than a pencil lead.

  • Sweetgum and sycamore

    Spiky balls and seed fluff that plug downspouts.

  • Any roof

    Sheds grit from the shingles. It is the sludge at the bottom of every gutter.

Thick layer of brown and orange fallen maple leaves covering the ground

How guards go on

  1. Clean first Every gutter and downspout is cleared and flushed. Guards over muck make things worse.
  2. Check the gutters Slope, hangers and corners. Anything loose is fixed before it is covered.
  3. Screw, not snap The frame is screwed to the gutter lip and tucked to the fascia. It does not go under the shingles.
  4. Hose test We run water down the roof onto the mesh, and watch every downspout.

No guard means no upkeep. Almost

Guards or cleanings: the sums

Open yard, one story

Two cleanings a year at $150 is $3,000 over ten years. Guards on 150 feet are $1,200. Close, so many people keep cleaning.

Either

Under oaks, one story

Four cleanings a year is $6,000 over ten years. Guards are $1,200.

Guards

Two stories, any trees

Cleanings run $250 each, and nobody should be up there with a bucket.

Guards

Guards, ice and snow

Ask anyone selling you guards

Questions about guards

Why are some guards $25 a foot?

Mostly sales commission and advertising. The materials are much the same. Ours are $8 a foot, since Nate measures, quotes and installs them himself.

Can guards go on my old gutters?

If they are sound and sloped right, yes. We check first, and tell you if they are not worth covering.

Will water shoot over the top in a downpour?

Not over micro-mesh at a normal roof pitch. On a very steep or metal roof, we fit 6 inch gutters or a diverter.

Do guards keep out birds and wasps?

Yes. Starlings and sparrows nest in open gutters, and mosquitoes breed in standing water. A sealed gutter stops all three.

Find out if you need them.

Nate will tell you straight. About a third of the time, the answer is no.